Dividend safety score explained

A dividend safety score squeezes one question into a single number: can this company keep paying its dividend? Dividend Score answers it on a 0โ€“100 scale. This guide explains what goes into that number, what the colors mean, why a red flag can override everything else, and how the Safety Score differs from its partner, the Strength Score.

What the number measures

The Safety Score combines six checks, each scored from 0 to 100 and then weighted:

Check Weight What it asks
Free-cash-flow payout (4-year average) 25% Is the dividend paid out of real cash?
Balance sheet strength 22% Can the company carry its debt?
Profit history (last 5 years) 18% Has the company made money consistently?
Earnings payout ratio 15% Is the dividend covered by reported profit?
Dividend growth streak 12% How long has the dividend held or grown?
Earnings stability 8% How much do earnings swing from year to year?

Cash coverage carries the most weight because a dividend is paid in cash, not in accounting profit. Each check is explained in how to tell if a dividend is safe, and the two payout checks in more depth in what is a good payout ratio? and the free cash flow payout ratio guide.

A worked example

A hypothetical company (not a real stock) scores like this on the six checks:

Check Points ร— weight Adds
FCF payout 80 ร— 25% 20.0
Balance sheet 77.5 ร— 22% 17.1
Profit history 100 ร— 18% 18.0
Earnings payout 55 ร— 15% 8.3
Dividend streak 65 ร— 12% 7.8
Earnings stability 75 ร— 8% 6.0
Safety Score 77

The total is rounded to a whole number: 77 out of 100.

When a check can't be measured

Sometimes a check has nothing to measure. A company with no debt, for example, has no interest coverage to calculate. When that happens, the check is left out and its weight is shared across the checks that remain โ€” it is not counted as zero.

If the company above had no debt, the other five checks would carry the full 100% between them, and the score would still come out at 77. Counting the missing balance-sheet check as zero would have dragged it down to 60 for no reason. The full analysis marks any check that couldn't be calculated, with the reason.

Red flags cap the score at 30

A weighted average can hide a single serious problem behind several good numbers. So three red flags override the average:

  • A net loss in the latest fiscal year.
  • A dividend not covered by cash: the latest year's dividend is larger than the 4-year average free cash flow, and it takes more than 90% of the latest year's operating cash flow.
  • A dividend yield above 8.5%, a level that often means the market expects a cut (see how to spot a dividend yield trap).

If any one of them fires, the Safety Score is capped at 30, however strong the rest looks. The example company above would drop from 77 to 30 if its yield rose above 8.5%. In the app, a capped score carries a "Red flag โ€” capped at 30" badge, and each stock page names the flag that fired.

What the colors mean

Scores are shown in three colors:

Score Color
80 and above Green
50โ€“79 Yellow
Below 50 Red

The colors are reading aids, not verdicts. A 79 and an 80 are almost the same score in different colors. Any score capped by a red flag is red, because 30 is below 50.

Safety vs Strength: two separate scores

Dividend Score gives every stock a second 0โ€“100 number, the Strength Score, which asks a different question: will this dividend grow? It weighs margin stability (22%), return on equity (20%), 5-year dividend growth (18%), 5-year total return (15%), today's yield versus the stock's own 5-year average (13%) and 10-year dividend growth (12%).

The two scores are calculated separately and never blended inside a stock's analysis. A mature company can be very safe and slow-growing; a fast grower can be strong but stretched. Reading them side by side tells you more than one merged number would. The only place they meet is the ranking list of scored stocks, which sorts by the average of the two.

What the score can't tell you

The Safety Score is built from past financial statements and dividend history. It doesn't know about next quarter's results, a pending acquisition or a board decision, and it relies on third-party market data that can be incomplete.

The thresholds are calibrated for non-financial, non-REIT US companies. Banks, insurers, REITs and utilities have their own payout and leverage norms, so their scores need extra care.

See any stock's Safety Score โ€” free

Dividend Score shows the Safety and Strength Scores for US dividend stocks, with every check behind them. Browse the scored stocks or read every weight and threshold on the methodology page.


Dividend Score is an informational research tool. Nothing here is investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Do your own research.